SEC asks crypto ETF issuers to withdraw 19b-4 filings after new listing rules

Criptolog » Coins » SEC asks crypto ETF issuers to withdraw 19b-4 filings after new listing rules

U.S. securities regulators have asked would-be crypto ETF providers to withdraw 19b-4 filings, a notable pivot that follows the approval of generic listing standards for commodity-based exchange-traded products. The move, described by a person familiar with the matter to CoinDesk, shifts much of the action to the registration side of the process.

Under the updated framework, certain crypto-linked ETPs that fit the standardized criteria can be listed by exchanges without submitting individual rule-change proposals. Issuers, in turn, will concentrate on the SEC-reviewed S-1 to detail each fund’s structure, strategy and risks, potentially shortening the runway to market.

What just changed in the rulebook

Earlier this month, the SEC cleared generic listing standards that let exchanges list commodity-based ETPs — including those tied to digital assets — without a bespoke 19b-4 for every product. That removes a procedural hurdle and leaves the substantive disclosure and risk review to the issuer’s S-1 filing.

Previously, the 19b-4 route required venues such as Nasdaq and NYSE Arca to seek permission to tweak their own listing rules each time a new product was proposed, a process that could stretch out for months. With that step reduced for eligible products, the bottleneck shifts to S-1 effectiveness.

How fast could approvals move?

Bloomberg Intelligence’s James Seyffart noted the agency can move remarkably quickly when it chooses, raising the prospect that greenlights could arrive within days — with the important caveat that nothing is guaranteed. Timing will depend on the complexity of disclosures and the SEC’s comfort with underlying markets.

Seyffart also pointed out that the conversion of Bitwise’s BITW into an ETF remains unapproved. He suggested the SEC could stick to a “first-to-file” convention common across the ETF industry, potentially resulting in staggered waves of launches or, depending on the assets, a coordinated start.

Which crypto ETFs are in the queue

Applications referencing spot exposure to Solana (SOL), Litecoin (LTC), Dogecoin (DOGE), XRP, Cardano (ADA) and HBAR have been cited by industry watchers as candidates affected by the change. Journalist Eleanor Terrett wrote that issuers may begin withdrawing 19b-4s imminently, adding that the SEC could act on one or many filings at any time.

Nate Geraci of ETF Store flagged approaching milestones, saying a decision window for Canary Capital’s Litecoin ETF was near, to be followed by other spot proposals tied to SOL, DOGE, XRP, ADA and HBAR. While windows exist, the agency is not bound to any one sequencing for S-1 effectiveness.

Prior coverage has referenced a cluster of final dates for as many as 16 spot crypto ETFs landing around mid-October. The updated process could compress or realign that cadence, depending on how quickly S-1 reviews advance.

Signals from regulators and market impact

Bitwise CIO Matt Hougan previously argued that approving generic listing standards could “open the market wide,” implying a faster path for a broader set of crypto exposures once the disclosure side lines up with the new exchange rules.

In a related development, regulators approved the CoinDesk Crypto 5 (GDLC) ETF under the new guidelines on September 19. The product is described as the first U.S. ETF tracking five leading cryptoassets by market value, including Bitcoin (BTC), Ethereum (ETH), XRP, Solana and Cardano, highlighting how the framework may support multi-asset approaches.

Outstanding uncertainties

Despite the streamlined listing mechanics, the S-1 review remains rigorous, and the pace at which the SEC clears registrations is inherently variable. Analysts also cautioned that a potential government shutdown could inject operational delays into some timelines, making precise forecasts tricky.

By steering issuers away from 19b-4s and toward S-1s, the SEC has effectively recast the approval workflow for certain crypto ETPs: exchanges can lean on standardized listing rules, while issuers shoulder disclosure. That combination could accelerate launches for products tied to assets like SOL, LTC, DOGE, XRP, ADA and HBAR, yet the ultimate timing hinges on staff reviews, market conditions and how the agency sequences approvals across a crowded docket.

Related article:

XRPR by REX-Osprey: First U.S. Spot XRP ETF Lists on Cboe and Draws Standout Day-One Demand